Friday, March 31, 2017

Russian Nuclear Subs Prowling Again

This article in the Washington Post describes the increased presence of Russian nuclear-armed submarines off the coast of the US, reflecting the same levels of presence that occurred during the height of the Cold War. With the decay of the Soviet bloc in the early 1990s, all of us hoped and thought that the Cold War is over. So much for hope. The Russians and Putin are right back in the same game, and maybe worse.



Before every Looking Glass mission, our intelligence briefing would include the status of Soviet nuclear-armed submarines and their locations. Typically, there were 3-4 that would lurk a few hundred miles off the East Coast. In those positions, they could strike Washington DC and New York City in 4 mins. Meaning, we had very little time to assess, decide, and react if under attack. After the Air Force, I spent two years as a civilian consultant to the Pentagon, working for TRW, studying this scenario and developing the policies, procedures, plans and computer-aided decision support systems to support it. Before this project, there was a tendency for US decision makers to overreact, guaranteeing nuclear escalation. It's all downhill to the end of the world after that.



Tuesday, March 28, 2017

Communicating During and After Nuclear Exchange

There is an intricate, complex network of redundant methods for communicating during the pre-, trans-, and post attack period of a nuclear war. As the Airborne C3I Officer aboard Looking Glass, it was my team's responsibility for managing this network and communicating over it.

One of those networks is associated with High Frequency (HF) radio communications. Here's a summary of that network, pasted below from here.

United States Air Force High Frequency Global Communications System (HFGCS)
(Updated 2014)

HFGCS History

HFGCS used to be GHFS.

GHFS (Global High Frequency System) began on 1 June 1992, when it
was created out of two earlier HF networks, the GIANT TALK used
by the Strategic Air Command, and the Global Command and Control
System (GCCS), used by the rest of the Air Force.  This change
reflected the reorganization of the Air Force following the end of
the cold war, with SAC becoming part of United States Strategic
Command (STRATCOM), TAC becoming the Air Combat Command (ACC), and
MAC becoming the Air Mobility Command (AMC; call sign "Reach").

GHFS became HF-GCS in 2003, on completion of the multiyear equipment
upgrade called SCOPE COMMAND, and nearly all control was moved to
Andrews Air Force Base in Maryland. Current HFGCS stations consist
of a receiver site, a transmitter site, and a control system. These
are extremely configurable and flexible, and they can be operated
remotely, locally, or any combinations of both.

Emission can be USB voice, Automatic Link Establishment (ALE), or
data modem. Most traffic on the main channels is voice, though a
large number of other channels exist for ALE autoscan.

At some point HF-GCS lost its hyphen, and now it's just HFGCS. The
station list, schedules, and procedures used to appear in an
unclassified flight manual, but this document has since become
secret.

More recently, in 2013, the ground stations for the most part have
stopped identifying broadcasts with their locations. This reflects
the full "lights out" automation of the system, and its extreme
flexibility. Usually, the identity of the specific transmitter
is no longer particularly relevant.

Currently, broadcasts are identified with "MAINSAIL." This is the
long-time group call sign for all ground stations. Similarly,
mobiles calling MAINSAIL can be regarded as a CQ to any ground
station.


Other HFGCS Facts

At one time, HFGCS was listed as providing the following services:
 Unclassified phone patches
 Message relay
 Mission following
 EAM broadcasts
 Data modem services
 Emergency assistance
 MIJI reports (Meaconing, Intrusion, Jamming, Interference)

RTTY has not been supported for several years now.

Phone patch traffic is down on this net, though a lot of it has
moved to MARS channel 13927 kHz USB. An ALE autodialer used to be
provided on 9025 kHz. Its status is unknown.

Remaining HFGCS Patches or long conversations can still be moved
to discrete frequencies, to free up the net.

Most traffic is EAM broadcasts. This stands for Emergency Action
Message, though very few are really national emergencies. EAMs have
the distinctive preamble of their first six characters and "Stand
By." The latter prosign reflects the high traffic precedence of
these coded military orders or bulletins, which exceeds most other
non-override traffic except for in-flight emergencies. Other
users are expected to stand by when one is in progress. This also
explains why EAMs don't listen first. They just start up.

SKYKING messages are special EAM, Emergency Action Messages,
presumably the nuclear go/no-go codes.  Urgent ones are repeated
three or four times, instead of the usual two.  SKYKING is a group
callsign for units in the Single Integrated Operation Plan (SIOP)
for strategic operations." "Do not answer" is the standard procedure
for self-authenticating broadcasts, meaning that recipients don't
need to give away their positions or existence by challenging the
traffic.

The distinctive touch-tone beeps (DTMF tones) are still on occasion
heard at the end of transmissions. These are left over from Giant
Talk, and they may eventually be replaced by another system. These
beeps key and unkey remote transmitters. The echoes heard are both
propagation delays and/or the result of slow landlines or satellites
linking the distant sites. Usually, it's the second one, because
the delays are too long for even the longest terrestrial paths.

One Giant Talk holdover is 6761 kHz USB, the old SAC night primary.
It is now used as an air-to-air channel. Though it's not technically
part of HFGCS, it is still used for coordinating in-flight refueling.

The status of 10780 kHz, the onetime backup at Cape Canaveral Air
Force Station, is unknown. There are reports that this radio asset
has been moved or dismantled.

From the start, HFGCS was intended for multi-service use.  It replaced
US Navy's Fleet HICOM (High Command), which phased out and is now
dead, though its frequencies are occasionally used for other purposes.
One also hears US Army vessels (yes, the Army has a "navy"). HFGCS
services are also available to any allies or other units authorized
by the US Department of Defense (DoD).

Finally, this leaves 6761, the former SAC night primary, as an
air-to-air channel.  Though it's not technically part of HFGCS, it is
still used for coordinating in-flight refueling.

At one time, the full information on HFGCS was available to the public
in the DoD FLIP (Flight Information Publications). These publications
have since been classified as sensitive, and at present they are
available in digital files to authorized users only.

Therefore, anything you see on the Internet is probably dated. The full
schedule has been removed from this web site, in order to prevent error
propagation.


HFGCS Lexicon:

A---            US Army callsign, usually a troop boat or terminal
AR              Aerial Refueling, usually with a track number
AUTODIN         Automated Digital Network
Block time      Final arrival time, when plane is in the blocks
Class A, B      Refers to explosive on board
CNCS            Centralized Network Control Station (Andrews)
DSN             Defense Switched Network, old "Autovon"
DV              Distinguished Visitor
FL              Flight level (altitude when higher up)
Hazmat          Hazardous cargo
IFE             Inflight emergency, as declared by pilot
IR              Instrument Route; aerial training routes
M&W             Morale and Welfare (patch)
MAINSAIL        General call: Any ground station this net
METRO           Base weather office
NIPRNET         Non-Secret Internet Protocol Routing Network
Offload         Fuel, in pounds
Pallets         Cargo
Pax             Passengers
PIREP           Pilot Report; weather observation with standard items
REACH           Standing callsign: any AMC flight.  Followed by
                tail or mission number, or a special code.
RON             Remain Over Night (crew needs place to sleep)
RTB             Return To Base, mission aborted
SAM             Special Air Mission (VIP)
SCOPE           System Capable Of Planned Expansion
SIPRNET         Secure Internet Protocol Routing Network
SKYBIRD         Group callsign: all STRATCOM assets on net
SKYKING         Group callsign: all SIOP assets on net



ALL FOLLOWING INFORMATION REFLECTS THE LAST PUBLIC PUBLICATION. NO
CLASSIFIED MATERIAL WAS DIVULGED IN PREPARING THIS DOCUMENT!


PRIMARY FREQUENCIES (kHz USB)

4724.0 6739.0 8992.0 11175.0 13200.0 15016.0

8992 and 11175 are 24-hour. Lower ones are used for traffic at
night, higher ones in the day time. EAM can be simulcast on any
of these.


USAF HFGCS STATION LIST
(Some may have closed)

Andersen Air Base             Guam (ALE: GUA)
Andrews Air Force Base        MD (ALE: ADW)
Ascension Island AF           S Atlantic (ALE: HAW)
Croughton AB                  UK (ALE: CRO)
Diego Garcia NS               Indian Ocean (ALE: JDG)
Elmendorf AFB                 AK (ALE: AED)
Falklands?                    S. Atlantic Ocean (ALE: MPA)
Hickam AFB                    HI (ALE: HIK)
Keflavik NAS                  Iceland (ALE: IKF)
Lajes AB                      Azores (ALE: PLA)
McClellan AF                  CA (ALE: MCC)
Offutt AFB                    NE (ALE: OFF)
Salinas                       PR (ALE: JNR; Voice: "Puerto Rico")
Sigonella NAS                 Sicily (ALE: ICZ)
Yokota AB                     Japan (ALE: JTY)

McClellan was known as "West Coast" for a time, but right before
everything went to MAINSAIL, it had gone back to the McClellan
name. The old base was closed under BRAC, but some air ops remain
at the site.  The SCOPE COMMAND radios are a separate activity
anyway.

Saturday, November 12, 2016

Thoughts on Veterans' Day, Nov 11, 2016

I was too young to fully grasp this event-- not quite 3 1/2 years old-- but I do remember when our family was notified, in Japan. It's the earliest memory I have as a child.

It was in early in the morning. We were in the kitchen. Dad was sitting at the kitchen table. I crawled into his lap-- he was wearing a white t-shirt, his face cradled in his hands, sobbing. I was trying to make him feel better, not fully understanding why he was crying so hard.


Thursday, November 10, 2016

Election of Donald Trump 2016

Again, this is a post that is intended primarily for our children, Anna and Luke, as a record of events and thoughts in their father's life that they might find interesting.

Closing thoughts on this weird day, Nov 9, 2016:

I voted for Hillary because Trump behaved in a way that was counter to every fiber of my upbringing. My Dad was a die-hard Reagan fan when Reagan was governor of California. Dad died before Reagan was elected President. That would have been a big moment. Mom followed Dad's lead when it came to politics, but after he died, she followed her own path of independence. Party didn't matter to her anymore. Morals and ethics mattered and she hated Trump because of that, before it was easy. Dad would have hated him because he was vile and crude to women, including his daughters...and because he was a city dude from New York, when dude meant dude.

I feel no remorse for Hillary's loss. I didn't like her anyway. She is the prototype career politician that is corrupting our political system and the very culture of the United States. And I can't mourn for someone who can't even beat Donald Trump. Dirtiest vote of my life.

I'm shocked by the people whom I know dearly and claim family values, yet feel no sense of guilt or filth from voting for Trump and celebrating him like a god damn hero. The hypocrisy kills me. I sure wish I could see a little more, "Trump sucks, but not as bad as Hillary", from you. I could understand that.

I want Mother Nature to know, if She starts getting even more trashed... And I want my gay, lesbian, Muslim, Black, and immigrant friends to know... if the shit hits the fan, I'll be there with you, joined by millions of others. You don't even have to call.

But here we are... and I'm going to pray and hope that Trump is the agent of good change that we need in American politics. I absolutely want him to be a great President for all of us. I absolutely want him to help Make America Great Again. Rather than wring our hands and expect him to be a demagogue, let's expect him to be great. Let's see if his ego can deliver on the brags.

G'night.


Wednesday, October 19, 2016

Story for Anna and Luke: My Old Denim Jacket

I've had this Lee Storm Rider jacket since I was a sophomore at Durango High School, purchased in the fall of 1975. Most every boy in high school at that time, wore a denim jacket. This one is insulated with a flannel liner, which made it very warm in those Durango winters, when winters were deep and cold, not like today.




Dad bought it for me at Basin Co-op. I only wear it about once or twice a year now; don't want it to fall apart. The left cuff has damage from battery acid-- from jump starting our tractor. I remember Dad warning me to clean it thoroughly as soon as possible, otherwise, it would "eat it away like cancer."

The jacket was stolen while I was at a party during college, probably in 1981. About a month after the party, I saw a fellow wearing it in downtown Durango at a bar-- The Sundance Saloon. I politely approached him, though I was pretty tense. He claimed the jacket was his. I said, "I'm pretty sure it's mine and if it's mine, there's a blood stain about the size of a thumb on the left sleeve just below the elbow."

A friend was with him and my friend, Steve Janes, was with me. The fellow lifted his arm up and we all saw the stain. There was about five seconds of awkward staring at each other, then he took the coat off and handed it to me without saying anything. I said thanks, and that was the end of that.

Steve was always much more interested in fighting than me, so he was a great backup, but I was definitely not going to leave without that coat. It had all sorts of sentimental value, especially since Dad had died just a couple of years before, in 1978.

Monday, October 10, 2016

Hacking Into Our Voting Systems

In 1993, Ron Gault and I met with the Federal Election Commission after our NSA-contracted team at TRW identified several very easy ways to hack into the then-emerging computerized voting systems. We warned the FEC about the possibility of election fraud and manipulation. Their response was interesting: (1) We don't regulate or certify voting systems; that's up to each state to manage; and (2) There are always errors in counting votes. We recognize there are inaccuracies but those inaccuracies are small compared to the total number of votes, and would therefore not impact the outcome.

Fast forward to the Gore/Bush runoff in Florida, where a few votes most definitely mattered. Fast forward again to today, and the sophistication of Russian hackers, as described in this Wall Street Journal article, "U.S. Intelligence Chief Suggests Russia Was Behind Election-Linked Hacks."

Our computerized voting systems are still an unregulated, unprotected hacker's dream. Their only saving grace is that they are, for the most part, only partially networked; thus the propagation of an attack is more difficult.

This is going to be a very interesting election.

Thursday, October 6, 2016

Memory for Anna & Luke: October 2011 with Grandma Sanders

I took this picture five years ago to the day, between Dunton and Rico, Colorado.

Oct 6, 2011 was my first day moving back home, after leaving Durango in 1983 for the Air Force. Coming back home was an easy, yet scary decision, not knowing exactly how I was going to earn a living or what it meant to my career. But it turned out to be one of the best decisions of my life. God took over.

This day was the first time that my mom, Ruby Sanders, had been on that road in over thirty years, since my dad, Doyle Sanders, died in 1978. She had lived alone ever since, but was always busy, loving and outgoing. I moved back to spend time with her while she was still healthy. Two and a half years later, she died in her sleep, in her bed, in her home of over 60 years, where our family was raised.

I spent a lot of time growing up, with my dad, hunting and exploring in these mountains, meadows and flats in the west fork of the Dolores River. When Mom and I saw this scene on this drive, it felt like a sign from Dad, "I'm here with you, pardner. You're back home. You're supposed to be here."


Russian Nuclear Subs Prowling Again

This article in the Washington Post describes the increased presence of Russian nuclear-armed submarines off the coast of the US, reflectin...